Globe Valve vs Ball Valve on Turbine Drains - Lessons from an Eskom Case Study
    Case Study

    Globe Valve vs Ball Valve on Turbine Drains - Lessons from an Eskom Case Study

    20 July 2026 6 min Valcon Technical Team

    Conventional globe valves fail rapidly on turbine drain applications — the extreme pressure drop, high velocities and vibration wear out valve internals so fast that, in a case study documented by US valve manufacturer Conval Inc., Eskom power stations were cutting out up to 70 globe valves per unit at every general outage. The documented fix: switching turbine drain duty to severe-service ball valves, while retaining forged Clampseal® globe valves where throttling and fine isolation suit the design. Conval valves are supplied in South Africa by Valcon Valve & Controls, the authorised Conval distributor.

    The Problem: Turbine Drains Destroy Conventional Globe Valves

    Turbine drain lines are among the harshest valve applications in a power station. The pressure drop across the valve is extreme, velocities rise sharply as steam and condensate flash through the trim, and the resulting vibration is severe and continuous.

    In the case study — published by Conval Inc. in the United States, based on their experience at South African power plants — conventional globe valves fitted on these drain applications suffered internals that rattled loose and wore out at a rate no maintenance budget could sustain. The result: up to 70 globe valves cut out and replaced per unit, every general outage.

    Think of it like fitting an ordinary passenger tyre to a mine haul truck. The tyre isn't badly made — it was never designed for that duty. A standard globe valve in a high-pressure-drop drain line faces the same mismatch.

    About this case study: the findings above were documented and published by Conval Inc. of Somers, Connecticut, USA — manufacturer of Clampseal® and Camseal® severe-service valves. Figures and application details are as reported by Conval America.

    The Fix: Severe-Service Ball Valves on Drain Duty

    According to Conval's case study, Eskom switched these turbine drain applications over completely to Conval ball valves. A ball valve in this duty presents a straight-through bore when open, with no plug and seat suspended in the flow path to vibrate and wear. Drain valves survive between outages instead of being cut out at each one — fewer welds, less scaffolding, shorter outage scope and a real reduction in maintenance cost per unit.

    Globe Valve vs Ball Valve on Turbine Drain Duty

    FactorConventional Globe ValveSevere-Service Ball Valve
    Flow path when openTortuous — plug and seat sit in the flow streamStraight-through bore, trim out of the flow path
    High pressure-drop drain dutyInternals rattle and wear under vibrationDesigned for high ΔP and flashing service
    Outage impactCut out, re-weld, re-insulate — repeatedlyTypically survives between outages
    Throttling / fine isolationExcellent — the right tool for this jobOn/off isolation duty
    Best applicationVents, PI point isolation, heater lines, ejectorsTurbine drains and other severe drain duty

    Where Globe Valves Still Win

    The same case study is just as instructive about where globe valves remain the right choice. One South African power station ordered nearly 1,000 Conval Clampseal® T-pattern globe valves in a single order — covering turbine and boiler drain legs and vents, small-bore HP heater lines, isolation valves at pressure-indicating points, air ejectors and condensers, all with live-loaded packing — delivered on time and at a competitive price.

    The takeaway is not "ball valves good, globe valves bad." It is that the application — pressure drop, velocity, vibration, cycling — must drive the selection. The two valve types are teammates in the same plant, not rivals.

    Typical Applications for Severe-Service Valves in Power Stations

    Turbine Drain Lines
    Boiler Drain Legs & Vents
    Small-Bore HP Heater Lines
    Pressure-Indicating Point Isolation
    Air Ejectors
    Condensers

    Why This Matters for South African Plants in 2026

    Eskom still generates the bulk of South Africa's electricity, and much of the coal fleet is being asked to run reliably for years to come. With outage windows tight and maintenance budgets under scrutiny, the economics in this case study are more relevant than ever: every valve that has to be cut out, re-welded and re-insulated at an outage is cost and critical-path time. Specifying severe-service valves correctly the first time is one of the cheapest reliability improvements a station can make.

    How Valcon Can Help

    As Conval's authorised distributor in South Africa, Valcon Valve & Controls supplies the full Conval range — Clampseal® globe valves, Camseal® ball valves, gate and check valves — with valve sizing and selection using manufacturer-approved software, genuine OEM spares and after-sales support for the Southern African power generation, petrochemical and mining industries.

    If you're fighting recurring valve failures on drains, vents or high-pressure steam service, send us the application details — size, pressure class, temperature and service — and we'll recommend the right severe-service valve for the duty.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Why do globe valves fail on turbine drain applications?

    Turbine drain lines combine extreme pressure drop with sharply increased velocities and severe vibration. A conventional globe valve holds its plug and seat directly in this flow path, so the internals rattle, wear and eventually fail. In Conval's documented Eskom case study, stations were cutting out up to 70 globe valves per unit at every general outage before switching to severe-service ball valves.

    Is a ball valve better than a globe valve?

    Neither is universally better — it depends on the duty. Ball valves excel at on/off isolation in high pressure-drop, high-vibration service such as turbine drains, because the open bore keeps trim out of the flow path. Globe valves excel at throttling and fine isolation on vents, heater lines, pressure-indicating points and similar applications. Most power stations need both.

    What is a severe-service valve?

    A severe-service valve is engineered for conditions that destroy standard valves: extreme pressure drops, flashing or cavitating flow, high temperatures, vibration and frequent cycling. Forged construction, robust trim design and live-loaded packing — as in the Conval Clampseal® and Camseal® ranges — are typical features.

    Who supplies Conval valves in South Africa?

    Valcon Valve & Controls is the authorised Conval distributor for South Africa, based in Kempton Park, Gauteng. Valcon provides sizing, selection, supply, genuine OEM spares and after-sales technical support for the full Conval range across Southern Africa.

    Does Eskom use Conval valves?

    According to a case study published by Conval Inc. (USA), Eskom power stations switched turbine drain applications to Conval ball valves after recurring globe valve failures, and one South African station ordered nearly 1,000 Clampseal® T-pattern globe valves for drains, vents, HP heater lines and isolation duty.

    Fighting Recurring Valve Failures on Drains or Vents?

    Send us the application details - size, pressure class, temperature and service - and we will recommend the right Conval severe-service globe or ball valve for the duty, with sizing support and genuine OEM spares.

    Enquiries go directly to the Valcon sales team